LP SmartSide vs Hardie: 2025 Costs Compared
LP SmartSide and James Hardie fiber cement siding deliver durable exterior upgrades that enhance curb appeal and safeguard the building envelope. Homeowners face choices influenced by costs, installation demands, and ongoing maintenance. This analysis examines pricing, return on investment, and key factors shaping real-world expenses for each option.
Cost, ROI, and Influencing Factors
Market and Perceived Value
Siding installations affect three key value areas. Market value reflects the measurable boost in resale price. Perceived value stems from buyers' views of quality and upkeep. Total cost of ownership encompasses materials, labor, maintenance, and repairs across the product's lifespan.
LP SmartSide and Hardie siding typically recoup 70 to 85 percent of installation costs upon resale. Regional labor variations, trim complexity, and alignment with neighborhood aesthetics determine the precise return.
Total Project Ranges
For a home spanning 1,800 to 2,400 square feet, expect to cover 2,000 to 2,600 square feet of siding, accounting for gables and material waste.
- LP SmartSide: $15,000 to $30,000 total
- Hardie: $19,000 to $38,000 total
These figures incorporate old siding removal, weather barriers, trim work, and paint or finish applications.
Cost Drivers
Removing and disposing of existing siding adds $1.00 to $2.00 per square foot. Projects with intricate walls or multiple levels demand extra staging and equipment, elevating labor expenses. Trim elements like fascia, corner boards, and window surrounds contribute $2,000 to $6,000.
Site access challenges or narrow lot boundaries extend labor hours. Opting for factory-applied finishes versus on-site painting influences upfront and recurring costs.
Scale Examples
- Small project (1,200 square feet): $9,000 to $15,000 for LP SmartSide, $11,000 to $18,000 for Hardie
- Mid-size project (2,000 square feet): $16,000 to $28,000 for LP SmartSide, $20,000 to $32,000 for Hardie
- Large project (3,000 square feet or more): $25,000 to $40,000 for LP SmartSide, $30,000 to $48,000 for Hardie
LP SmartSide generally costs 10 to 25 percent less than Hardie for initial installation. However, Hardie's extended repaint intervals may balance this advantage over 20 to 30 years.
Design for Curb Appeal
Massing and Proportion
Select siding profiles that complement the home's architecture. Narrow lap siding (4 to 5 inches) softens the appearance of tall vertical walls. Wider exposures (6 to 8 inches) enhance horizontal lines on ranch-style homes.
Align seams consistently around windows and doors to maintain visual harmony and prevent a fragmented look.
Color Depth and Undertone
Both brands provide versatile neutrals such as grays, taupes, and warm whites that perform well in photographs. Darker shades conceal dirt effectively but may fade under intense sunlight. Lighter colors promote heat reflection and expand the perceived size of compact homes.
Test color samples under varying natural light conditions prior to final selection.
Entry Emphasis and Detail
Incorporate smooth trim to outline doors and windows with precision. Position house numbers and lighting fixtures at uniform heights for a polished entry.
Introduce one focal accent, like shingle panels in gables or vertical siding sections, to establish visual interest without overwhelming the design.
Balanced contrasts and precise lines convey meticulous care, appealing to potential buyers and minimizing upkeep perceptions.
Maintenance and Longevity
Cleaning and Care
Maintain siding with a soft-bristle brush, mild detergent, and low-pressure garden hose. Refrain from using pressure washers exceeding 1,500 psi, as they risk damaging protective finishes.
Schedule cleanings annually or following periods of heavy pollen or debris accumulation.
Finish and Paint Cycles
LP SmartSide requires repainting every 8 to 12 years, based on sun and weather exposure. Hardie extends to 12 to 16 years with factory finishes, though field-applied paints shorten this interval.
Examine caulk joints each year and renew any that show cracks or separation.
Inspection and Protection
| Task | Interval | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Wash siding | Yearly | Remove dirt and mildew |
| Inspect caulk and flashing | Yearly | Prevent moisture entry |
| Repaint or refinish | 8 to 16 years | Maintain color protection |
| Check foundation splash zone | Twice yearly | Prevent wicking and rot |
Warranty Overview
Each product features limited warranties spanning multiple decades, applicable to manufacturing defects but excluding installation faults. Retain all records, including photos and contractor invoices. Neglecting paint or caulk maintenance could invalidate claims.
Regular inspections and careful cleaning sustain appearance and value over decades.
Selecting and Living with Your Siding
Properly installed LP SmartSide or Hardie siding enhances resale potential significantly. Choices hinge on priorities like material weight, finish options, and budget constraints.
Opt for LP SmartSide if ease of handling, quicker installation, or a wood-grain aesthetic takes precedence, despite more frequent repaints. Select Hardie for fire-resistant properties and reduced long-term maintenance, even at a higher starting price.
Maintain uniform trim dimensions and subtle color contrasts throughout. Capture professional photographs in daylight post-installation to record the upgrade and support future sales efforts.
Pro Tips for Success
- Verify proper moisture control by adhering to manufacturer guidelines for weather barriers and flashing.
- Prime or seal all cut edges daily to protect against water intrusion.
- Ensure adequate ventilation around rooflines and decks per specifications.
- Compile comprehensive documentation, including images and receipts, for warranty purposes.
- Coordinate colors with neighboring properties, favoring neutral bases paired with sharp trim for broad appeal.
Troubleshooting Common Issues
Can LP SmartSide replace existing Hardie boards? Yes, provided adjustments account for differences in thickness and joint patterns. Ensure trim and flashing align to prevent uneven surfaces.
What if paint starts peeling early? Investigate for moisture trapping or unprimed edges. Address underlying issues like caulk failures before recoating, avoiding coverage of unresolved problems.
Long-Term Value Summary
Investing in LP SmartSide or Hardie siding secures enduring protection and aesthetic appeal. By weighing initial costs against maintenance and ROI, homeowners achieve exteriors that withstand time and enhance property worth. Strategic design and diligent care maximize these benefits for years ahead.